Ponies in bold and italic are most wanted
2004
”Super Long Hair Pony” Babies
Baby Romperooni**
Baby Bellaluna
Baby Goody Gumdrop**
2005
Target Exclusive Baby Ponies
Baby Penny Candy**
Baby Hula Lula (Grail)**
Baby Charm Bracelet
Baby Lavender Locket
Winter Baby Ponies
Baby Jingle Jangle (preferably with accessories) (Holy Grail)**
Baby Ribbons and Bows (preferably with accessories) (Holy Grail)**
Avon Catalogue Set Babies
Baby Tea Lily
Baby Wave Catcher
2006
Sister Sets
Baby Dance Around**
Baby Mocanut**
Target Exclusive Baby Ponies
Baby Hokey Pokey
Baby Boogie Woogie
Baby Northern Lights (preferably with scarf)(Holy Grail)**
Baby Winter Ice (preferably with scarf)(Holy Grail)**
Building Playset Babies
Baby Island Adventure**
MLP is copyright to Hasbro